When it comes to American barbecue, the conversation often gets dominated by low-and-slow classics from places like Texas and the Carolinas. But a different style of barbecue, from California's Central Coast, is equally compelling: Santa Maria-style. It’s a method that celebrates the straightforward, honest flavor of beef cooked over a live fire, and its signature cut, the tri tip, has earned a devoted following.

Note: This post contains affiliate links to Amazon or other providers and advertisements for which Old Man's Meat Lab earns a commission should you make purchases. These commission payments are at no additional cost to you.

This is a style that resonates deeply with anyone who appreciates the pure taste of meat without a lot of fuss. The idea for this post came to me on a trip to the supermarket. I’d seen a tri tip roast on sale and, being a big fan, I headed over to pick one up. To my dismay, they had sold out. While it was a letdown, I wasn't going home empty-handed. I ended up grabbing a two-pound sirloin roast, a more expensive cut but one that proved to be equally delicious and cooked up beautifully using the exact same technique.

That experience was a perfect reminder of what makes this method so great: its adaptability. While tri tip is the traditional choice, the Santa Maria style is a testament to the power of a simple rub and high-heat grilling, proving that a quality piece of beef, regardless of the specific cut, can be transformed into a masterpiece.

What is Santa Maria Style Barbecue?

To understand the appeal of Santa Maria tri tip, you have to appreciate its history. The tradition dates back to the mid-19th century, when ranchers in the Santa Maria Valley would hold large feasts. They'd grill large cuts of beef over pits filled with the coals of native Coast Live Oak, or "red oak," which imparts a unique, smoky flavor. The meal was simple and hearty, often served with local pinquito beans, salsa, and grilled French bread.

Over time, the process evolved, with butchers popularizing the tri tip in the 1950s. This triangular cut from the bottom sirloin was once considered a throwaway, destined for ground beef or stew meat. But when grilled over a hot fire with a basic seasoning of salt, pepper, and garlic, its rich, beefy flavor and tender texture made it a regional sensation. Today, it’s often referred to as "California's Cut."

The Santa Maria method is defined by three key elements:

• The Meat: Traditionally, a whole tri tip roast, though as I found out, a sirloin roast works wonderfully as a substitute.
• The Rub: A simple yet effective dry rub, usually featuring salt, black pepper, and garlic powder.
• The Fire: Live, open-fire grilling, ideally with red oak, which provides a distinct smoky character. A high-quality grill and good charcoal or wood chunks can help you replicate this at home.

The goal isn't to mask the flavor of the meat but to enhance it. The high-heat grilling creates a beautiful sear and crust, while a simple basting sauce adds moisture and a tangy counterpoint.

Now the original Santa Maria recipe and menu was copyrighted by the local chamber of commerce, so with a full caveat, my recipe is not exactly that, but I think the simple rub and flavorful basting sauce bring together a similar flavor profile that lets the beef shine. It's probably more accurate to say my recipe is Santa Maria influenced.

Preparing the Roast

The key to a truly flavorful Santa Maria tri tip starts with the dry rub and a little patience. Once you've mixed the simple rub of salt, pepper, paprika, rosemary, onion powder, and cayenne, you'll coat the roast on all sides. After applying the rub, place the roast in a container, cover it with plastic wrap, and refrigerate it for 3-4 hours. This essential step allows the flavors from the rub to meld and penetrate the meat, building a deeper flavor profile from the inside out. While the roast rests, you can prepare the basting sauce, a vibrant mix of oil, vinegar, garlic, and herbs.

Mastering the Grill: The Key to a Perfect Tri Tip

One of the most common mistakes people make with a tri tip is thinking it should be cooked like a steak. While it's part of the sirloin, it's best treated as a roast. Our recipe calls for high-heat grilling, a technique that allows you to get that perfect crust while keeping the inside tender and juicy.

The shape of the tri tip—thicker on one end and thinner on the other—is a benefit, not a challenge. It allows you to achieve different levels of doneness across a single roast. The thicker part can be cooked to a perfect medium-rare, while the thinner end can be taken to a medium or even medium-well for those who prefer their meat a little more done. It's a crowd-pleasing cut by design.

The real secret lies in the simple basting sauce and turning the roast frequently. This is not a set-it-and-forget-it recipe. By turning the meat every four to five minutes and basting it each time, you build up layers of flavor and ensure an even cook. The sauce, with its red wine vinegar, oil, and herbs, not only keeps the meat moist but also helps create that fantastic crust.

Need a basting brush? This Silicone Basting Brush Set from Amazon should work great.

The Recipe and the Results

Once the grill is preheated to high, the real work—and fun—begins. Placing the roast over direct high heat, you start the process of building the crust. The basting is your key to success, adding a layer of flavor with each turn. The entire process only takes about 20-30 minutes, which is remarkably quick for a roast of this caliber.

Watching your temperature is important, and I recommend using an instant-read meat thermometer. Cooking to a specific internal temperature—I recommend 130°F—ensures perfect results every time. Once you hit that mark, you remove the roast and let it rest for at least ten minutes. This is a non-negotiable step that allows the juices to redistribute, guaranteeing a tender and moist final product. Slicing against the grain is also key to ensuring every bite is as tender as possible.

Here's an Instant Read Meat Thermometer from Amazon.

The finished product is a thing of beauty: a deep, mahogany-colored crust that gives way to a juicy, perfectly cooked interior. The flavor is a symphony of simple, savory notes from the rub, the tangy complexity of the basting sauce, and the subtle smokiness from the grill. It's beef, elevated.

Whether you're using a traditional tri tip or a sirloin roast, this recipe delivers a taste of California history that is both simple to prepare and unforgettable. It's a perfect example of how a few key steps and a straightforward approach can turn a great cut of meat into a masterpiece.